A Passionate Plea from a Porteous Pal Friday, Mar 28 2008
Opinions 9:10 pm
Below is an e-mail from Dick Chopin, a prominent attorney and friend of U.S. District Judge Tom Porteous, who is facing impeachment based on recommendations from the Fifth Circuit’s Judicial Council. Evidently, some of the judges on the panel were in support of Judge Porteous and essentially dissented. But no dissent was ever published. Who were these judges and why did they disagree? Are they sworn to secrecy? If not, they should come forward and state their views here on The Weathers Report.
* * *
Friends and colleagues,
I am sure that most, if not all, of you are aware from the news, that Judge Porteous is being subjected to another round of “investigation”. The news has reported for years about its investigation and that of the FBI & the Justice department and neither have ever been able to identify any acts of impropriety on his part. This time an effort is underway to impeach him even though he has never been charged, much less convicted, of any crime. Long after the news was reported that the Judicial Council of the Fifth Circuit made certain recommendations it came to light that several judges on the panel had written in support of Judge Porteous and, basically, dissented. Several of us were shocked that the dissent was withheld from the media and believe this is blatantly unfair and absurd. I recommend you read James Gill’s recent column about this being withheld. A group of us decided to write letters expressing our views. I am asking that you consider also writing a letter on behalf of Judge Porteous.
For your convenience, I am attaching a copy of a letter from the Judicial Conference of the Untied States addressed to Judge Porteous. The Judicial Conference has apparently assigned this to Judge Ralph Winter of the 2nd Circuit (his address is 141 Church Street, New Haven, Connecticut 06510) and the matter was delayed for 30 days, until April 10, 2008. I am also attaching a copy of the letter I have written in support of Judge Porteous. In the event you decide to write a letter it must be in the hands of Judge Winter on or before April 10, 2008.
Please understand that I am making this request of you, not Judge Porteous. The judge did not ask me to do this but I feel it is imperative that the lawyers and public express their dissatisfaction with trial by ambush and innuendo.
I would ask that you also consider asking your friends and colleagues to write letter on behalf of Judge Porteous.
Regards
Dick
Chopin, Wagar, Richard & Kutcher, LLP
3850 North Causeway Blvd.
Cheaters sometimes win but they can also get sued. A former St. Louis Rams player and some attendees at the 2002 Super Bowl in New Orleans have filed a 





As the BCS national championship game in New Orleans approaches and LSU and Ohio State begin final preparations for Monday’s slugfest, Louisianians have begun shutting down their lives in eager anticipation.


Santa Claus is expected to arrive in New Orleans at 10:15 p.m. CST this Christmas Eve, a spokesperson for 











